From pints in cosy pubs to the best crazy & cool cocktail bars around, Sheffield has so many independent pubs and bars to choose from! Whether you’re after cosy winter vibes or somewhere to watch the footy in summer, we’ve put together some of our favourites. Recommended by our team who have lived in Sheffield for over a combined 50 years!
Fagan's
Fagan’s is an award-winning, Guinness-themed Irish pub nestled in the heart of Sheffield. It was taken over 37 years after the pub first opened, by a group of passionate Sheffield locals who were determined to keep this traditional gem alive. With five nights of live music, a perfectly poured pint of Guinness, and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s a go-to for a great night out. We collaborated with the Fagan’s team to create aprons made from repurposed workwear, featuring their signature logo — a true reflection of the pub’s character.
69 Broad Ln, Sheffield City Centre, S1 4BS – Get Directions
Public
Once described as "a Wes Anderson train carriage crowbarred into an old bog," Public is a speakeasy-style underground bar. Housed in a former gents' toilet, it’s a hidden gem where you can enjoy unique cocktails made with locally foraged ingredients and seasonal produce, all in a cosy, off-the-beaten-path setting just outside Sheffield city centre.
23-55 Surrey St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2LG Get Directions
Pearl at Park Hill
A recent addition to Sheffield's bar scene, Pearl at Park Hill is a sister company to the popular Bench. Expect expertly crafted drinks and a vibrant atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed night out. Our team loved it here, and we’re sure you will too!
8 Pat Midgley Ln, Sheffield S2 5QX – Get Directions
Hymn to Ninkasi
Get Directions The Wedge, 5 Cotton Mill Walk, Sheffield S3 8DH
Hymn to Ninkasi is a small, intimate craft beer bar tucked into The Wedge in Kelham Island. With a constantly rotating selection of local and international beers on tap, it’s a haven for beer lovers seeking something unique. The relaxed, minimalist space encourages conversation, discovery, and a love of well-crafted brews — a must-visit for anyone wanting to explore Sheffield’s thriving craft beer scene.
The Grapes
Get Directions 80 Trippet Ln, Sheffield City Centre, S1 4EL
A classic Sheffield pub with character, The Grapes is beloved for its welcoming atmosphere, hearty pub food, and great selection of beers. With cozy interiors and a friendly vibe, it’s perfect for a casual lunch, a relaxed evening drink, or catching up with friends. A staple of the city centre, it combines traditional charm with a lively, social energy.
